Seattle John Doe: Who the Hell is this Guy?

UPDATE, 3/24/08:

John Doe has been identified. He is Scott Andrew Shain, age 53. According to Seattle TV station KING 5, Shain was identified by his parents after they saw his photo on the FBI's website. Thanks to commenter "WOW" for the update and the link. Further updates may follow.

ORIGINAL ENTRY:

The balding, blue-eyed man is medium height, weighs about 170. His age is a mystery. He could be 40, he could be in his early 50s. In every photo he wears the same expression, and it's hard to dismiss the impression that he's smirking. He is holding onto a secret, something he'll never willingly tell another. He currently sits inside the SeaTac Detention Center in Seattle, Washington, facing a number of charges -- charges that include aggravated identity theft.

No one knows who he is. To that end, he's even tried to obliterate his own fingerprints.

The FBI started looking into John Doe more than 5 months ago. The Royal Canadian Mounted Police contacted the FBI, curious about Seattle resident Dwayne Spill. Spill had tried to get birth certificates from British Columbia and from Saskatchewan.

The Feds first talked to the man in late 2007. He called himself Robert Lowe, but the nameplate on his residence read "D. A. Spill."

The investigation revealed more names. Photographs from Washington State driver's licenses tied the names together. All the licenses bore photos of the same ageless, smirking man. In some he wore wigs, others he wore glasses. But his face was unmistakable. Beside that face were names like:
  • William Gregg;
  • a variation on Robert Lowe, spelling the last name "Loew";
  • William Everett Gee;
  • Blake Matthew Desmond;
  • Bernard O'Daly;
Federal agents believe John Doe has used at least 32 identities over the years.

An investigator with the Social Security Administration's Office of Inspector General, Joseph Velling, spoke to the Seattle Times about Doe. The Feds may know who the man is now, but they aren't sure. "He is a little bit of a savant, to tell you the truth," said Velling. He continued, "It's hard to remember anything quite like this."

Doe was clever. In Massachusetts he was Bernard O'Daly (only one man with this name from Massachusetts shows up on the Social Security Death Index -- he died in April, 1979). When he moved west, he had that name legally changed to Blake Matthew Desmond.

Special Agent Velling told the Times that Doe has lived in Massachusetts, Washington, Oregon, Colorado, Wyoming and Idaho. Doe has a criminal record as well -- under some of his aliases.

His most recent arrest wasn't Doe's first encounter with Federal agents. Doe was interviewed 15 years ago by the Secret Service after he allegedly threatened Bill Clinton. They confiscated a homemade flamethrower from the man at the time.

Velling also indicated that Doe may have had some involvement in what he called a "sort of eBay or Craigslist for criminals."

Though Doe is facing charges of mail fraud and identity theft, investigators haven't found much evidence of the mystery man using his various identities to commit any other crimes. He may be hiding from something, he may simply be paranoid.

Doe hasn't helped anyone. He simply sits in jail, no doubt with the same mysterious half-smile on his face much of the time, waiting for his next court date.

Sources:

True Crime Sites of Interest

In spite of the abiding interest in the subject matter, new true crime-related sites don't pop up all that often -- at least in my experience. And believe me, I look for them.

Generally, the ones I hear about come through my e-mail or a random link from another site. Here's a few for you to peruse at your leisure.

CRIMEBLOG.IT

The site's name would be pretty clever in English, but fair warning -- CrimeBlog.it is not a clever use of a foreign domain extension like Trench Reynolds's CrimeNe.ws -- it's an Italian language true crime blog. The focus is on crime in Italy, but the blogger also covers unusual and bizarre crimes from the US and elsewhere. Entries are short and punchy and the subject matter is a little more varied than you'd find here.

I can read Italian but I do have to use online translation sites at times. Based on the knowledge I do have of the language, Google's may be the most accurate, but you can also try Babelfish, the venerable online translator run by Altavista.

I decided to point you to this site in part because I know this blog has Italian readers and readers who speak the language, and also because some hair-rising true crime tales come from the land that also gave us opera and yummy, yummy pasta. Don't believe me? Just look up the Monster of Florence.

CRIMEJUNKIES.COM

I'm not going to say a whole lot about CrimeJunkies.com here, because I've asked the site owner to do a guest blog post. I don't think I'm giving anything away when I say the site looks like it will live up to its name. It's brand new, but CrimeJunkies.com has (or will have) just about everything the most hard-core true crime fan wants from a website focusing on their addiction.

WOMENINCRIMEINK.BLOGSPOT.COM

Before I wrote about crime I was a fan of the genre. And as a fan, I always knew I was in the minority, for it seems that women are the most active consumers of true crime related literature (and the best-selling author in the genre is a woman). It was, after all, my mother's interest in the subject that got me started. If you saw a copy of Helter Skelter laying around our house, or even True Detective magazines, they were my mom's. My alpha male military Dad was apparently a little skeeved out by the whole thing.

Plenty of men write about crime, of course, but the number of female readers of this blog and other sites I'm familiar with has recently had me wondering why someone didn't think up a blog like WomeninCrimeInk a long time ago. The high-powered roster of blog authors includes award-winning true crime authors, broadcasters, attorneys, journalists, even a homicide detective.

The result so far is a well-written and engaging blog that never veers into the tabloid or lurid -- hopefully a nice complement to the one you're reading now (though I fully admit that some ready-for-the-tabloids stories can't help but make it onto my site, from time to time). A recommended read, for sure.

ADDED LATER: 320SYCAMORE.COM

320Sycamore.com seeks to be a "destination for Crime Interested Individuals! Explore and engage in activities, research, and talk that matters to you."

The site is structured like an online town. Knowing the way a little community can develop over a single subject here at The True Crime Weblog, this is a model that makes a lot of sense to me. The best way to approach 320Sycamore.com is simply to do as you might in any new place and take a little ramble around. The site is laid out fairly well and seems much more amenable to community discussion than many straight-up just plain weblogs.

If you have any suggestions for new sites similar to the ones listed above, put them in the comments.

A note of warning, though -- don't come here and just spam me with a blurb for your site in a comment. I will delete it as quickly as possible, and I may ban your IP as well. Let me be specific about this -- I never mind links to other sites -- ever. But I do mind it if you have some sort of cut & paste boilerplate you're simply posting willy-nilly all over the Web on any site with, let's say, "crime" in the URL. I've only ever received a handful of those comments, but they never fail to make me angry. To me, that's the height of real rudeness on the Web. If you want to promote your own site by posting it in a comment, it better be relevant and acknowledge the subject at hand. Otherwise, you might as well be a spam link for Viagra.

Maine Gothic: A Boy and His Mother

Even Maine's most famous horror novelist couldn't make this up. Well... he could, but it'd probably be too disturbing, depressing, and tawdry for him to bother.

Just before midnight on Sunday, Matthew Audet, age 22, called police in Lewiston, Maine. He told them his 47-year-old mother Debra wasn't breathing. According to police reports, Matthew Audet said his mother might have attempted suicide. She'd "grabbed her own larynx" and "might have choked herself out."

Police found Audet in the apartment he shared with his mom, kneeling on a mattress beside her body. Debra Audet was unresponsive and had no pulse.

Matthew Audet was sticking to the suicide story. His mom had tried it before, he told police. Audet demonstrated what he meant to the officers on the scene by grabbing his own throat with both hands and making gagging noises.

Cops naturally wanted Audet to come down to the police department, but they made it clear that he wasn't under arrest. Audet's response was odd -- he stuck out his arms and pressed his wrists together, saying, "I'm ready."

The cops didn't handcuff Audet. He persisted, walking to the police cruiser with his arms behind his back, wrists touching.

Also living in the apartment with Audet and his mother were Matthew's wife, Kayla, age 19, and a man named Jaime Arsenault, age 30.

Once police talked with Kayla Audet, a different story came to light.

Debra Audet didn't commit suicide.

Everyone in Apt. 4 had been drinking that night, according to Kayla. She and Matthew were tossing back 40s, but Debra Audet's drinks of choice were "Night Train" and "Mad Dog 20/20."

Mother and son were drinking together in Debra's room. Kayla wasn't with them. She and Matthew had been having problems. Matthew drank too much for Kayla's taste, among other things. She told Matthew that she wanted to leave him. An intense argument ensued, culminating in both dashing their wedding rings against the wall.

Kayla took a shower after the fight, then went to her room to gather her belongings. She heard Matthew calling for her.

She ignored his calls at first, but finally she went to Debra's room to see what he wanted. That was when she saw Debra's pale form, the dead woman's tongue protruding from her mouth.

Kayla Audet was scared. She went to the bathroom to grab a few things, and Matthew followed her, saying, "I killed my mom."

Matthew made a half-hearted attempt to keep his wife from leaving, but she did leave. Kayla went to a friend's house, where she told her friend what had just occurred in the Audets' apartment. Shortly after Kayla arrived, they heard the police cars going to the Audet residence, so Kayla went back to talk with the cops.

The most bizarre aspect of the story would come from the friend with whom Kayla sought refuge, identified in police reports as Regan Tims.

Tims told investigators that Debra Audet had a sexual relationship with her son. Tims said the relationship may have begun when Matthew was a boy, 8 or 9 years old. Regan Tims's story grew even stranger. She'd talked with Debra earlier that Sunday, she said, and the elder Audet had recounted an argument she'd had with Matthew over a separate relationship.

That relationship, according to Regan Tims, was between Debra Audet and Matthew's wife, Kayla. Tims said that Ms. Audet's relationship with Kayla began while Matthew was doing a stint in the military.

Police reports indicate that investigators got Kayla Audet to confirm her relationship with her mother-in-law. Kayla said she had no 'specific knowledge' of a sexual relationship between Debra and Matthew.

In the end, Matthew Audet seemed to come clean about what happened in his mother's room. He told of the drinking and hanging out with his mom, and of how she'd begun to harangue him. He wasn't working enough, she had cancer and they'd be sorry when she was gone, and... Kayla was cheating on him.

That was it, for Matthew Audet. The police report states that he grabbed his mother, thinking he'd just "calm her down." In the end, 'calm down' allegedly meant Audet's hand on his mother's throat for at least 30 seconds.

An autopsy on Debra Audet confirmed that she'd been strangled.

Sources and links:

Accused Rapist Shawn Wuertley: Background Check, Anyone?

Some people can't get jobs if they have bad credit. Then there's accused rapist Shawn Wuertley, age 29 (link goes to his MySpace page).

Wuertley was arrested today in Panama City Beach, Florida for false imprisonment, rape and attempted felony murder.

According to multiple media sources, Wuertley was working as a security guard at the Sandpiper Beacon Beach Resort when he dragged an 18-year-old resort guest from Tuscaloosa, Alabama into an unoccupied room on the 6th floor at the resort and raped her. They struggled after the assault as the girl tried to get away. In the process, Wuertley allegedly shoved the victim off a balcony.

The girl fell onto a 2nd floor stairwell. Her injuries were said to be serious but not fatal. Wuertley was questioned by police and allowed to go. He fled, only to be arrested sometime today in Bay County, Florida.

The Panama City News-Herald reports:
[Maj. Dave Humphreys of the Panama City Beach Police Department] said police at the scene began to suspect that Wuertley might have been involved and took him to the police station, where they photographed and questioned him.

"There was not enough information at that point to charge him," Humphreys said.

He said investigators did not run a criminal history check on Wuertley until after he was released. That's when investigators discovered the Indiana arrest warrant on a burglary charge.

"We’re certainly checking into why that wasn’t done,” Humphreys said. “It should have been done."
Wuertley has been running afoul of the law for some time now, you see. He had a long rap sheet from his home state of Indiana, and as recently as 2006 was in a Mooresville, IN correctional facility.

Yes, the police should have run a check on Wuertley as he sat with detectives answering questions -- but let's admit it: the real pressing question is how a guy with Wuertley's record got a job working security at a beach resort. The real scrutiny should be on hiring practices here, now that police in Bay County (FL) have Wuertley safely behind bars.

There are plenty of jobs, particularly positions involving any kind of security work, that require full, exhaustive background checks. Even bad credit or bankruptcy can torpedo an applicant.

Even if Shawn Wuertley's prior criminal history was non-violent, the News-Herald reported that it included "burglary, escape, auto theft," as well as shoplifting and possession of marijuana. There was also an outstanding warrant for burglary in Indiana. How was that missed during the hiring process? No one can convince me that there are that many Shawn Wuertleys from Mooresville, Indiana out there.

Investigators have indicated that Wuertley may have simply lied on his application for the position at the resort.

That's all it took for him to snag a job? Amazing.

A double failure, and for the family of a young woman from Tuscaloosa, a tragedy. Even though the victim survived the attack, she now may face a lifetime of physical and emotional trauma, the likes of which few of us can imagine.

This post may be revised and updated.

Additional links:

Shawn Wuertley's Yahoo 360 profile

Discussion of this crime at Websleuths.com

OPEN THREAD: Continuing Discussion of the Murder of Meredith Kercher

I must admit I'm not fond of open threads. Essentially, it's like letting a bunch of strangers take over a blog post, and I guess I'm territorial enough to be bothered by that. But I can't deny that some readers love them. I'll never be able to put up with the anarchy of a generalized open thread, where people can theoretically discuss whatever is on their minds, but certain subjects covered by this blog tend to demand open threads.

So, since folks have remained relatively -- and I mean relatively -- civil, here's a new open thread for discussion of the murder of British student Meredith Kercher in Perugia, Italy last November. You can click the tags at the bottom of this post to find past entries in this blog about this case.

Please maintain a civil dialogue, and please do NOT bring arguments from other blogs to this one. In that respect, I remain apologetically protective of this space. If you started an argument elsewhere, finish it there, or forget about it. Please be courteous to any new posters, and if you express suspicion of who they really are, what their purpose is, please have a grounded, rational reason.

This post is yours, now -- have at it.