Suburban Gothic: A Standoff in Dallas

An abusive husband and father's last stand went on for at least 7 hours in Arlington, Texas on Friday. The stand-off ended with water rather than gunfire.

NBC 5 in Dallas reported that prior to the standoff, Arthur Jackson IV took his daughter to the Mayfield Road Baptist Church in Arlington. The 4-year-old little girl was said to be covered in blood but otherwise unharmed. Jackson stated while at the church that he'd 'committed a crime.' He was also drenched with blood.

The crime the man allegedly commited was the murder of his wife, Lisa Ford-Jackson and his stepchildren: a 13-year-old girl and a 10-year-old boy. The children have not been named. The three were found in a home near Lake Arlington, 10 miles or so from the site of the standoff.

Tarrant County (TX) property tax records showed that the couple owned a home at 2101 Mims Street. Other Tarrant County records showed that Lisa Lynette Ford married Arthur Jackson IV in March, 2003. The murdered stepchildren were Lisa's kids from a previous relationship, the 4-year-old was the product of Arthur's and Lisa's marriage.

The Dallas Morning News reported that police in Fort Worth had been called to the Jackson residence at least twice in recent months. One call was from Arthur, who said he was worried about his kids being left by themselves, the other call was from Lisa, who said that her husband was harassing her, knocking on the door and repeatedly ringing the doorbell.

Arthur Jackson IV finally forced an ending to his confrontation with police. As noted by Jules in the comments left on this post, he pulled out of the driveway where he'd been since early in the afternoon and led the police on a short chase that ended with his vehicle sinking into Lake Arlington.

Reader KatK left this link in the comments below this entry. MyFox Dallas reported that Arthur Jackson shot himself as the vehicle sank into the lake.

An AP story about the standoff contained a statement that seemed weirdly familiar. The kind of thing neighbors so often seem to say when men commit astonishing acts of violence. A man who lived near the Jacksons said the following about the allegedly murderous Arthur: "He was the friendliest guy around [. . .] He was a happy go lucky guy. Every time I saw him, he had a smile."

Seems like they always do. A smile makes for excellent camouflage.

*****
This post marks the introduction of two new ideas for The True Crime Weblog: An active use of the term "Suburban Gothic"; and a possible change in the way certain blog entries are written.

I certainly didn't invent the idea of "Suburban Gothic." But I have often felt that I had a unique take on the meaning of that term. I was raised in a strange situation. My family lived in a home set well back from a rural State road. Our nearest neighbors until I was 16 or so were all family. I knew other boys and girls in the area and even played with them, but the point is this -- I didn't live in the suburbs. They were just across the road, for a long time through a half-mile wide stretch of woods. Riding my bicycle through a field to the road where the suburbs began was for me like entering a completely different world just a mile from my home. From perhaps 7th grade onwards I entered the suburbs as a stranger in a strange land much of the time, and that perception has never left me. It informs how I view certain crime stories -- therefore, it will become for the purposes of this weblog a label (or category, if you think in terms of the Wordpress blog publishing program) that I use whenever I cover certain crimes in the news.

The change in how entries are written isn't big, but it will be noticeable. Rather than doing as so many bloggers do and posting sometimes numerous updates, I will simply begin editing and adding to entries as I go. Therefore the blog entry you are reading now may look very different tomorrow. It may contain a great deal more information on the crime being covered, as well as re-written passages. Other portions may be removed, redacted, etc. This is similar to the system certain newswires and newspapers appear to use for online articles.

At a certain point, of course, new entries for a given subject will be necessary. And updates can't be completely abandoned, style-wise. Sometimes they make sense.

I decided to make this slight change because looking back over old posts I sometimes found updates distracting, even confusing. Hopefully using re-writes and add-ins instead will make for a reading experience that ages better -- that is, if someone is reading this post a year from now, it will make more sense and be more coherent than it might be if it were a bunch of updates. I also got tired of ending each entry on a developing story with some variation on "this entry will be updated." This is one where you can assume that will happen if you are reading the post within an hour of its publication. Otherwise, I may no longer add that note to each post I plan to add to later.

Klutzo the Clown and his International Travels

Springfield, Illinois resident Klutzo the Clown was arrested October 9, 2007 and charged with possession of child pornography. Authorities allege that Klutzo, who is actually named A. (for Amon) Paul Carlock, Jr., took photos of nude little boys at an orphanage in the Philippines.

It's tempting to make some sort of joke relating to Krusty the Clown and that other Springfield, but there's really nothing funny about this story, if you just stop and think about it.

On paper, Paul Carlock Jr. looked like a true pillar of the community, the kind of guy you might actually want to be around your kid: he'd worked over 2 decades in law enforcement, as a Juvenile Counselor for the Illinois Department of Corrections; he'd been a patrolman and then a Youth Division detective for the Springfield PD; he was an ordained minister.

Carlock frequently performed as a clown with his wife -- he was Klutzo, she was "Smilee." No hint of anything inappropriate could be gleaned from the couples' website (his wife is not charged with anything and may have even filed for divorce):

clowncapers.esmartkid.com/index.html [link goes to archived version, original site down].

If the charges against A. Paul Carlock Jr. are true, he was a predator. Hindsight makes some messages that Carlock left on the Web look more suspicious than they probably seemed when he made them.

According to the complaint filed against Carlock by the feds, he was stopped at the San Francisco International Airport on June 12, 2007 in part because he was coming from the Philippines, and that country is "considered high risk for child sex tourism and child pornography."

Carlock said he'd been there to visit an orphanage named "House of Joy."

He also said he'd been there before.

This appears to be the home page for the "House of Joy."

A guestbook could be found here. A third of the way down the page was this message, left sometime prior to 2006 -- emphasis has been added:

I hope everyone is fine there. From your site it seems that all is well.

I hope to come again sometime in 2006. Would love to clown at the schools while there.

If it is possible, I would like to stay busy by helping your house parents. Maybe they could take a few days off with pay while I fill in for them free of charge.

God Bless
Paul Carlock "Klutzo"
Springfield, Illinois USA

The next mention of Klutzo associated with the "House of Joy" was found halfway down this web page:

House of Joy has a visitor from Illinois, USA. He is Paul Carlock, a policeman and a professional clown. He will stay for 3 weeks.
His daily schedule was very busy because he go to one school to another to share his talent to the children.
Mr.Paul Carlock, thank you for entertaining the children of House of Joy and the Children of San Isidro.

The photos accompanying the blurb about Klutzo were all uploaded in February, 2004.

Paul "Klutzo" Carlock Jr. had photos with him when the authorities stopped him in June, too. They were, according to the complaint, "numerous images of nude young males," who were between 5 and 10 years of age. The boys were shown "playing, showering, and sitting clothed but with genitals visible." Some children were aware of the camera, others were not.

A. Paul Carlock Jr. from Illinois also had an Amazon profile. He said he was a "filmfanatic," and he'd reviewed 10 movies. The movies are interesting by themselves, but it is more illustrative of where Carlock was coming from to note the "tags" he used for the movies he liked. Again, emphasis has been added:
boy (3), devotion (2), loyalty (2), bonding (1), child (1), coming of age (1), comitment (1), commitment (1), crafty (1), endearment (1), goofy (1), hope (1), kidnapping (1), love (1), miracle (1), mischievous fun (1), moving (1), parenting (1), relationship (1), silly (1), socialization (1), trickster (1)
It isn't the sort of evidence that would make it into a court case against Carlock, but again, in hindsight, it is hard to read the list of tags above and not nod and think, "it figures." To read Paul Carlock's reviews of various DVDs, most of them with children prominently displayed on the covers, click here.

Carlock tried to explain his way out of the situation in San Francisco. He said of the nude children, "That's how they live."

But by mid-September, the jig was up for Klutzo. Authorities in the Philippines interviewed three children, a 9-year-old and two 10-year-olds. From the October 9th complaint against Carlock:
All three minors made sworn statements in which they stated that they woke up to Paul Carlock fondling and caressing their penis and that he walked out of the room when they awoke.
Back in the States, Carlock's wife told investigators that Klutzo had been in the Big Brothers program for about 2 months. A 6-year-old boy was assigned to Carlock.

The boy was interviewed. He had not been molested, but one of the two DVDs he'd been given by Carlock held photos of nude filipino boys and girls.

Investigators had seized computers and other media from Carlock by the end of September. The complaint stated that they found more than 20 movies on various items taken from Carlock's home -- all of it child pornography.

The feds will have the last laugh on Klutzo the Clown.

Consider, though -- Carlock was born in 1949, and by his own account, he's been "involved in pastoral ministry, Christian education, Christian camping and evangelism since 1967."

Reading about how Paul Carlock was into "Christian camping" (whatever that is) 40 years ago was enough to induce some queasiness. After all, how long could this "orphan toucher's" (thanks, BelchSpeak) trail of victims be? Surely he didn't start "touching" in his 50s?

If Carlock is guilty of molestation, child-sex tourism, and the child porn charges against him, he has been a demonstrable hypocrite for more than 20 years. The Peoria Journal Star reported the following on October 10:

In December 1986, Carlock wrote a letter to the State Journal-Register complaining about a cartoon. In it, he said he was a conservative Christian and not ashamed of the fact.

"I am not in favor of censorship, but do feel that far too much 'smut' has been poured into the minds of Americans by all forms of media," he wrote.

"I have spent the past 16 years in law enforcement and related professions. I have spoken with victims and offenders and have read many case histories in which pornographic materials played an overwhelming role in the events that have left lives shattered and homes broken."

Later in the letter, he wrote: "Why is it so unreasonable to assume the government has the right to protect the public from the harmful effects of pornography (especially in light of the vast amounts of evidence to support this claim)?"

There are plenty of adults who have an appropriate interest in children. Coaches who just want to teach kids to love a game, to enjoy sports. Teachers who feel called to mold young minds: Ministers, rabbis or [even] priests who feel led to teach children spiritually.

When people want to bemoan a culture of fear, where a normal adult male might walk away from an unfamiliar child crying and alone in a shopping mall for fear of being viewed as a predator if he speaks to the kid, they are forgetting the reason that fear has grown -- stories about guys who play the clown.

Tubby, funny, surely endearing, and just waiting for the time when the orphans finally fall asleep.

Magnanimous in their casual offers to help beleaguered single parents, foster parents, house parents, always "free of charge."

UPDATE, 10/12/2007

The Springfield (Il.) State Journal-Register has a new article about Carlock up today. The lede is a statement that should come as no surprise:
One thing appears certain. Wherever A. Paul Carlock Jr. was, children were not far away.
Go figure.

UPDATE 2

Word to the wise: Know which Klutzo is which, people. Some poor schmuck named Jerry Kautz had been using the same clown moniker for ages, and naturally (since the world is chock full of incredibly stupid people) after Amon Paul Carlock Jr. was arrested, poor old Jerry started getting hate mail and death threats.

*Sigh.* I just hope none of those nimrods read any of my blog entries.

Other Source: "Christian Clown Busted For Kiddie Porn," WaPo's OFF/beat Weblog.

This entry has also been published at In Cold Blog.

***UPDATE, 11/19/07***


The story of Klutzo the Clown ends strangely. Go here to see what I mean.

Carnival of the True Crime Blogs #97

Let's begin the 97th edition of the Carnival of the True Crime Blogs with the pros, and a fascinating post made October 8 at In Cold Blog, by author Ron Franscell. Ron asks a question in his post that surely has occurred to a good number of true crime writers, from beginning crime bloggers to pros with books on the bestsellers lists: "Natural or Nurtured? Are Sociopaths Born?"

Next up are the guys at Crime Rant, commenting on the tragic mass-murder in tiny Crandon, WI: "Tyler Peterson: Wasted (Lives) in Wisconsin."

Here at the True Crime Weblog, I've done a follow-up on the shocking case of Missouri pedophile Michael Devlin and the young people he abused: "According to Michael Devlin, Michael Devlin is Guilty."

Crime, Interrupted has an unsettling story about an alleged female pedophile who sometimes calls herself "Pixiedust" (ew!): "Four Corners Creep of the Week: Michelle Tufts."

At CLEWS, The Historic True Crime Blog, leading true crime historian Laura James interviews a British true crime author who has written a book about one of the most fascinating serial killers of the 20th Century, Austrian-born Jack Unterweger: "CLEWS Interviews True Crime Author John Leake."

Finally, the ever-eclectic and interesting 1947 Project tells us about "Those Monkeys in City Hall" and the hapless owner of a simian who partied in the palm trees one day in downtown L.A. in 1927.

That's it for this week's Carnival of the True Crime Blogs -- click away, and follow links from the other weblogs. You'll find that True Crime online can become a scarily addictive pursuit, and the links above are just gateway "drugs."

By Popular Demand: Open Thread for Madeleine McCann

There is no end to public fascination with the disappearance of the little British girl from Praia da Luz early last May.

Because several requests have been received, the purpose of this post is to simply start the discussion and let readers go.

To give some focus to the discussion, this article could be considered suggested reading.

The piece relates the news that Portuguese police may be looking for DNA and fingerprints the Britons who were at the Mark Warner-owned resort when Madeleine disappeared.

Apparently there were samples found there that investigators would still like to identify.

Detectives may be chasing signs of a kidnapper, after all.

If they are... well, what the hell happened to pointing the finger at Madeleine's parents, physicians Kate and Gerry McCann?

If you prefer to read comments in-line -- beneath the entry, on the blog itself, do the following once you've entered your comment:
* Instead of clicking "comment", click the title of the post ("By Popular Demand..."), then scroll down and enter your comment in the box. Some people seem to find the pop-out box that comes when you simply click "comment" from the blog's main page confusing;

* After you press "publish", press "F5" on your computer keyboard. You may also click the "refresh" button on your browser -- usually a looped arrow
.
Comments have a 3,000 character limit, and the Haloscan format doesn't like overly-long URLs.

I am considering opening a thread to discuss the murder of Chicago-area pharmaceutical sales rep Nailah Franklin, but there were a few trolls following those entries before. Normally, that wouldn't be a problem, but while I'm adding old entries to this site and making other improvements I don't have the time or patience to mess with that sort of nonsense.

As always, please keep the discussion civil and on-topic. Any off-topic, offensive, or frankly, just plain stupid posts may deleted and the user banned.

The way you close comments with Haloscan doesn't really close them. The previous thread at this blog (TrueCrimeWeblog.com) can be reached here.

According to Michael Devlin, Michael Devlin is Guilty

As the authors pointed out at CrimeRant.com -- "Devlin Did it -- Even He Says So."

The former Missouri pizza parlor managing pedophile pleaded guilty Monday morning to abducting one of his two alleged victims.

Specifically, 41-year-old Michael Devlin copped to a charge of child kidnaping and a charge of "armed criminal action." These charges were for Devlin's forced abduction of 13-year-old Ben Ownby on January 8, 2007.

Devlin has more hearings this week in multiple jurisdictions. It looks as though he will plead guilty to all 80+ charges he faces in relation to his crimes against Shawn Hornbeck, now 16, and Ben Ownby.

According to an AP article, Mikey is pleading to everything "for the kids." One of Devlin's lawyers reported that the man wanted to 'spare his family and his longtime captive, Shawn, the anguish of a trial.'

Big of him, don't you think? Nice to know Mikey is finally concerned about the boys.

As if.

For the previous entries here at The True Crime Weblog about Mr. Devlin and his victims, just click this link. This was one of the first weblogs to really jump on this horrific story, and the tale of Michael Devlin and his victims nearly dragged this usually resolutely non-political blog into a political debate when the oh-so-political Bill O'Reilly said some execrable things about the whole deal.

Fortunately, Bill jumped the shark in other ways since then (losing some ratings battles to Olbermann, for one thing), and he has plenty of other chains dragging him down into madness.

At least Devlin will be where he belongs, now (until there's a new opening in Hell) and his victims may be able to one day put some of this behind them. God willing.

UPDATE, 10/09/07

Chris linked a story in this comment that really makes you stop and think about Michael Devlin, and just what kind of monster he was.

Devlin was going to strangle Shawn Hornbeck to death after he'd kept him and raped him for several days. Hornbeck talked him out of it. Then Devlin raped him again.

It's one of those things where just stating it baldly emphasizes how horrifying the story is.

Devlin had returned to the area where he abducted Shawn to do this, too.

It is difficult to believe that he hadn't done that sort of thing at least once before, to a kid who wasn't as quick-thinking as Shawn. I hope investigations into the possibility are continuing in Missouri, Illinois, and any other place where Devlin was known to have traveled.